Internet Startup Valuation The 'Desi Touch'

Author: Arun Balakrishnan
CEO & Founder,
Arriving at the valuation of an internet startup is considered as an art, which is perhaps the best mask for the cluelessness of an entrepreneur and the generalization done by investors. This labyrinth is a byproduct of varied subjectivity with a large focus on the qualitative rather than quantitative valuation methods like P/E comparable or discounted cash flow methods. The limited data available on comparable companies and industry benchmarks has only contributed towards the complexity. There also exists a significant amount of survivorship bias, which effectively ignores the results of Internet start-ups, which get shutdown. This problem gets further accentuated given the nascency of venture capital (VC) in India.

The off-shoot of this valuation mismatch has been the limited number of investments in seed stage and early stage ventures. Attributing the lack of pathbreaking products like Google, YouTube and Twitter from Indian entrepreneurs due to lack of creativity, would be a huge misnomer. The product development support for such ideas is missing from the Angel and VC fraternity of India. Thus, the divide that has been created, is because the risks of - venture capitalists not aligned with the valuation and capital expectations, of Indian entrepreneurs, who use their silicon valley counterparts as a benchmark.

Financial projections presented by entrepreneurs in India, are generally, a haphazard assortment of perceived expectations, irrational confidence, and market defiance and excel modeling of maybe about 2-3 hours. Therefore, besides the validation of common valuation variables, also significant adjustments have to be made to the valuation, keeping in mind the consumer behavior, Indian Internet industry and the Indian entrepreneur psyche. The value and weights of these adjustments depends on the impact they have on the business model and should be taken on venture to venture basis.

The primary task is to arrive at a base valuation of the start-up, which can be done through either the Terminal value method by Professor William Sahlman or the Probability Adjusted Present Value (PAPV) method. The effectiveness of the PAPV method in the Indian context is impugnable as both the volume of start-up investments and quality data available on them is low. In the terminal value method, usage of arbitrary assumptions for earnings multiple and P/E ratio can result in a value, which is discordant with the true value of the start-up. The P/E ratio of a comparable firm being used should be congruous with the stage of the life cycle of the internet start-up.

Positive Adjustments to the Valuation

Skills in the Management Team: The two skills, which are paramount to an internet start-up, are

1. Product Development
2. Sales

A founding team consisting of PhD and technical degrees from pedigree institutes ensures that the product development is in sync with the latest technological developments. The educational background can also be substituted with experience of at least 3-4 years in a large internet company. For sales, industry contacts are paramount and employees with relevant sales background in the industry contribute to the accelerated growth of revenues. In a nutshell, founding team of engineering graduates and acquired sales skill can be valued more than a founding team of management graduates and acquired product development skills.

R&D and stealth mode investments: Very few start-ups in India focus on good product development and testing in stealth mode before launch. The pressure from angel investors to launch as soon as possible also contributes significantly to the cause. So a start-up that has devoted time to research and product development should be given the due credit. Research is something, which has never been the focal point of businesses in India, and seldom have you come across a start-up in India akin to, which was in stealth mode for a period of almost nine months for the alpha version launch and then another nine months for the beta launch.

Patent Protection capability: In case of product patents filed in India, the end product is patented and not the process for developing that product. Coupled with the weak Indian patent laws, it means that, an existing competitor can replicate the product with minor tweaks to the finished product. So a product with marginal innovation, but tougher replication process, has a competitive advantage over a highly innovative product with a reasonably easy replication process.

Entrepreneurs financial and time commitment: Culturally Indians are risk averse and an entrepreneur, who has shown the commitment to the venture by investing his own money as well as sweat equity should be duly compensated with a better valuation. A serial entrepreneur does come with its merits, but should be taken in the Indian context with a pinch of salt. Given the low capital requirement and ease of developing an internet product, lot of college students can boast of having run a start-up. Care should be taken in not overvaluing this experience.

Negative Adjustments to the Valuation

Customer Acquisition method: Contrary to belief about seven years ago, the customer acquisition cost through search engine and digital marketing with respect to the potential revenue per customer is very high in India. So any business, which is transaction oriented with high dependency on search engine traffic faces a huge risk if it does not have an inherent sticky factor. The travel websites like Makemytrip, Yatra and Cleartrip being the prime examples where the customer acquisition cost takes a significant chunk out of them, as such, wafer thin gross margins.

New Product New market: Blue ocean strategy in India makes up for only a good read, with most of the investments being in new products with existing markets. For good revolutionary products to be made the angel investors/venture capitalists should be willing to experiment with a new product and a new market. The risks associated with this are definitely high and the entrepreneur should be willing to settle for a lower valuation given the proportionately higher risk being borne by the investor.

Advertisements as primary source of revenue: A combination of factors like limited Internet population (81 Million), broadband penetration (5.3 Million) and low revenue potential per user, results in denying an Internet product - the requisite scale that it can become a multimillion dollar enterprise solely on advertisement revenues. The battle of monetizing the traffic is one, for which the top Internet sites of India fight everyday.

A paradigm shift in risk-return calculation, which factors in some demographic specific qualitative factors, is the need of the hour. If the above parameters are factored into the valuation, then the return expectation of an investor can surely be conciliated with the capital and valuation expectation of the entrepreneur. Without the collaborative effort of the investors and entrepreneurs, it will be difficult to “stumble upon” world class Internet products in the Indian entrepreneurial ecosystem.

Write your comment now

Email    Password: 
Don't have SiliconIndia account? Sign up    Forgot your password? Reset
Reader's comments(6)
1: Much true as defined in by used old cars
Posted by: Saahil Sinha - Monday 12th, August 2013
2: From: Mrs. Mary David

This mail may be a surprise to you because you did not give me the permission to do so and neither do you know me but before I tell you about myself I want you to please forgive me for sending this mail without your permission. I am writing this letter in confidence believing that if it is the will of God for you to help me and my family, God almighty will bless and reward you abundantly. I need an honest and trust worthy person like you to entrust this huge transfer project unto.

My name is Mrs. Mary David, The Branch Manager of a Financial Institution. I am a Ghanaian married with 3 kids. I am writing to solicit your assistance in the transfer of US$7,500,000.00 Dollars. This fund is the excess of what my branch in which I am the manager made as profit last year (i.e. 2010 financial year). I have already submitted an annual report for that year to my head office in Accra-Ghana as I have watched with keen interest as they will never know of this excess. I have since, placed this amount of US$7,500,000.00 Dollars on an Escrow Coded account without a beneficiary (Anonymous) to avoid trace.

As an officer of the bank, I cannot be directly connected to this money thus I am impelled to request for your assistance to receive this money into your bank account on my behalf. I agree that 40% of this money will be for you as a foreign partner, in respect to the provision of a foreign account, and 60% would be for me. I do need to stress that there are practically no risk involved in this. It's going to be a bank-to-bank transfer. All I need from you is to stand as the original depositor of this fund so that the fund can be transferred to your account.

If you accept this offer, I will appreciate your timely response to me. This is why and only reason why I contacted you, I am willing to go into partnership investment with you owing to your wealth of experience, So please if you are interested to assist on this venture kindly contact me back for a brief discussion on how to proceed.

All correspondence must be via my private E-mail ( for obvious security reasons.

Best regards,
Mrs. Mary David.
Posted by: mary lovely david - Monday 26th, September 2011
3: Hi my dear,
My name is Mounace, i would like to establish a true relationship with you in one love. please send email to me at ( i will reply to you with my picture and tell you more about myself. thanks and remain blessed for me,
Your new friend Mounace
Posted by: mounace love love - Thursday 09th, June 2011
4: India will be the export for Toyota Etios

Posted by: lokesh krishnan - Thursday 11th, November 2010
5: I want to know more about start up valuation

My car
Ford Figo
Posted by: lokesh krishnan - Wednesday 10th, November 2010
6: Simple, yet very useful! I like the focues on trying hard to make both entrepreneur and investor happy. It is the foundation for successful collaboration between the two parties.
Posted by: Andrea Parmeggiani - Tuesday 12th, January 2010
More articles
by Kaushal Mehta - Founder & CEO, Motif Inc..
The retail industry is witnessing an increased migration of customers from traditional brick and mortar retail to E-commerce (online retail)...more>>
by Samir Shah - CEO, Zephyr .
You probably do because you are on the phone with them! For all of you working in some technical management capacity here in Silicon Valley,...more>>
by Raj Karamchedu - Chief Operating Officer, Legend Silicon .
These days are a mixed bag for me. Of late I have been considering "doing something bigger and better," in my life, perhaps seriously though...more>>
by Madhavi Vuppalapati - CEO of Prithvi Information Solutions .
IT Services Rise of Tier II companies The Indian IT outsourcing industry is going through very exciting phase in its business life...more>>
by Bhaskar Bakthavatsalu- Country Manager, India and SAARC of Check Point Software Technologies.
Data loss occurs every day through corporate email. In fact, given the sheer number of emails an organization sends every day, data loss inc...more>>