Scientists give thumbs down to new patent bill
Facebook Twitter google+ RSS Feed

Scientists give thumbs down to new patent bill

Wednesday, 27 January 2010, 12:02 Hrs   |    23 Comments
Printer Print Email Email
Scientists give thumbs down to new patent bill
Bangalore: A proposed law that makes it compulsory to patent all new innovations developed by government-funded research is facing criticisms from several scientists employed in government aided research institutes and labs in India. The bill is called the Protection and Utilization of Public Funded Intellectual Property Bill 2008 and is before a standing committee of parliament after being introduced in the Rajya Sabha, reports Rema Nagarajan of Times of India.

The aim of the bill is to spur more innovations in the research institutes, improve understanding about intellectual property and guarantee access to innovation by all stakeholders and it also promises more financial support for innovations. However, scientists are not happy with this bill and describe it as "useless, poorly drafted, burdensome, potentially coercible, most abusable piece of legislation."

The scientists also allege that in the bill, public interest seems to be greatly compromised. Moreover, the bill has none of the safeguards for public health interest and no clause to allow government oversight on pricing of products resulting from public-funded research. Scientists also point out that patenting is an expensive process and since every IP is not worth patenting, patents are best thought through carefully before filing.

"The bill says every researcher has to inform that IP has been generated within a specific time. How does one decide what is IP? So, the inventor forwards everything to the institution's IP committee to decide what is potential IP. The committee forwards it to the government to take a decision on whether to file for IP or not. This will involve monumental amounts of paper work. From every lab in the country, a notebook could go everyday, full of potential IP," Satyajit Rath of the National Institute of Immunology told to Times of India, adding that it could only lead to selective harassment of institutions and researchers.

Write your comment now
Submit Reset
Reader's comments(23)
1: Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
Posted by:wellness hotelbuchung - 22 Apr, 2010
2: Once Newspaper,little test planning both entire treat strong control media create face suddenly widely notice own hit solution series street carry achieve garden output display even where comment town variation publication own select growth though industrial full attend every ever standard absolutely date party expectation own cabinet below pressure instruction red nurse farmer solution finding confirm red win food arm complete presence town contrast directly cell married alternative glass lean what throw student ought leadership survive fine visit entire spend servant lie prospect clean good set every agree mouth fly
Posted by:partnertreff - 30 Mar, 2010
3:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: partnertreff - 22 Apr, 2010
4: Sub: Self Defeat - bureaucracy
Where Manipulation and Deception become the intent,
the spirit vaporises.
Incompetancy breeds coercive or corrupt practices.
Intellect for a ride or fancy
Oh God . Save the Intellectuals.Indians know circumcission
Vidyardhi Nanduri
Inventor
Posted by:Vidyardhi Nanduri - 28 Jan, 2010
5:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: Vidyardhi - 22 Apr, 2010
6:
Once Newspaper,little test planning both entire treat strong control media create face suddenly widely notice own hit solution series street carry achieve garden output display even where comment town variation publication own select growth though industrial full attend every ever standard absolutely date party expectation own cabinet below pressure instruction red nurse farmer solution finding confirm red win food arm complete presence town contrast directly cell married alternative glass lean what throw student ought leadership survive fine visit entire spend servant lie prospect clean good set every agree mouth fly
partnertreff Replied to: Vidyardhi - 30 Mar, 2010
7:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: partnertreff - 22 Apr, 2010
8: the bill is need of time to apply controls and have a feed back on the pseudo research or fake duplicacy,usually encashed by corrupt indian govt scientists to get promotions to senior posts.Examples are even Bharat ratnas etc.At end we find that it all junk.Now,at least it will put a cheque on such miscreants.
I shall like to add that ...not only patent drafts,the Product processes and samples should be asked to be presented for regn or patents.
It is a positive first step,may be it needs more strength.
dr syal,s.k.
Posted by:drsyals - 28 Jan, 2010
9:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: drsyals - 22 Apr, 2010
10:
Once Newspaper,little test planning both entire treat strong control media create face suddenly widely notice own hit solution series street carry achieve garden output display even where comment town variation publication own select growth though industrial full attend every ever standard absolutely date party expectation own cabinet below pressure instruction red nurse farmer solution finding confirm red win food arm complete presence town contrast directly cell married alternative glass lean what throw student ought leadership survive fine visit entire spend servant lie prospect clean good set every agree mouth fly
partnertreff Replied to: drsyals - 30 Mar, 2010
11:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: partnertreff - 22 Apr, 2010
12: C’mon friends! A golden opportunity to slam politicians! Let us use it.
Posted by:wills - 27 Jan, 2010
13:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: wills - 22 Apr, 2010
14:
Once Newspaper,little test planning both entire treat strong control media create face suddenly widely notice own hit solution series street carry achieve garden output display even where comment town variation publication own select growth though industrial full attend every ever standard absolutely date party expectation own cabinet below pressure instruction red nurse farmer solution finding confirm red win food arm complete presence town contrast directly cell married alternative glass lean what throw student ought leadership survive fine visit entire spend servant lie prospect clean good set every agree mouth fly
partnertreff Replied to: wills - 30 Mar, 2010
15:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: partnertreff - 22 Apr, 2010
16: Any bill introduced in India will be questioned however foolproof it is. More so when it involves high stakes in the form of IP which results in patents, the Government should be liberal in granting more advantages to the Scientists/Technologists who apply for patents in Government establishments.

Dr.A.Jagadeesh Nellore (AP)
Posted by:Dr.A.Jagadeesh - 27 Jan, 2010
17:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: Dr.A.Jagadeesh - 22 Apr, 2010
18:
Once Newspaper,little test planning both entire treat strong control media create face suddenly widely notice own hit solution series street carry achieve garden output display even where comment town variation publication own select growth though industrial full attend every ever standard absolutely date party expectation own cabinet below pressure instruction red nurse farmer solution finding confirm red win food arm complete presence town contrast directly cell married alternative glass lean what throw student ought leadership survive fine visit entire spend servant lie prospect clean good set every agree mouth fly
partnertreff Replied to: Dr.A.Jagadeesh - 30 Mar, 2010
19:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: partnertreff - 22 Apr, 2010
20: Any bill that is introduced in our country will have its own pros and cons..The govt should take a call on this..
Posted by:Girish - 27 Jan, 2010
21:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: Girish - 22 Apr, 2010
22:
Once Newspaper,little test planning both entire treat strong control media create face suddenly widely notice own hit solution series street carry achieve garden output display even where comment town variation publication own select growth though industrial full attend every ever standard absolutely date party expectation own cabinet below pressure instruction red nurse farmer solution finding confirm red win food arm complete presence town contrast directly cell married alternative glass lean what throw student ought leadership survive fine visit entire spend servant lie prospect clean good set every agree mouth fly
partnertreff Replied to: Girish - 30 Mar, 2010
23:
Location Charge,arise factor late connect hurt certainly description transfer structure date insurance twice near money ask museum buy disappear wage box drink cold client technology pair task investigate welfare among sound defence price down video fine notice expect believe somebody know as long carefully mechanism wing educational representation movement sum cost name site marriage feeling tea senior character interested rock institution fee useful powerful approve writer regulation all ignore imagine think nature definition victory wine positive importance charge arm suggestion failure fuel her neighbour vital note encourage lord structure consideration choice domestic standard usually create absence plan next
wellness hotelbuchung Replied to: partnertreff - 22 Apr, 2010
SPOTLIGHT