Will IIMs fall back on paper-pencil CAT?
By
SINS
| Sunday, 13 December 2009, 19:06 Hrs
|
Ahmedabad: CAT students are still unclear on whether the IIMs will be considering another online test or will it revert back to the old fashioned paper pencil method. According to sources close to the development, opinions have changed over the last five days, especially with the number of candidates affected by computer glitches rising to 20,000, reports Economic Times.

On Sunday, Prometric, the agency responsible for conducting the computer-based MBA entrance exam, gave a presentation to the IIM directors and members of the CAT committee in Mumbai. The presentation was essentially about data from CCTV recordings and computer logs to know the magnitude of glitches. However, the officials refused to say whether any conclusion was reached on the 10-day test that had to be extended by one-day. "The important thing is that, we now have the data. We will analyze it and then take a decision (on whether re-test would be held in the old format). It is too early to comment on anything else," said IIM-B Director Pankaj Chandra.
The Mumbai huddle is seen as a preparatory exercise before the crucial MHRD meeting scheduled for Wednesday. It may be mentioned here while the directors of IIM-Ahmedabad and IIM-Bangalore are not in favour of scrapping the test, the heads of other five IIMs prefer a re-test. With doubts raised over the fairness of the test, there is a consensus among other IIMs (except IIM-A and B) that a re-test would silence all critics. "This is not to say that it is the end of road for computer-based tests. This, being the first year, we faced a lot of hurdles. But we see a lot of gains in the new format. So, next year, we would be better prepared," said an IIM Professor.
It is feared that a re-test may throw the entire academic schedule haywire. If the IIMs decide to hold the test in the old format this year, the CAT organizers would take at least two more months to accommodate 2.41 lakh candidates at various colleges and institutes across the country. The admission process would also be delayed, leaving lesser time for the 2010-11 academic year.
The first demand for scrapping the online exam came from the coaching centres on the fifth day. The trainers form a prominent stakeholder, as close to two lakh candidates take tutorials for the career-defining exam that opens doors to seven IIMs and over 150 B-schools. Apart from the technical glitches, the trainers said, questions were repeated handing out an unfair advantage to those taking the test in the later slots.

On Sunday, Prometric, the agency responsible for conducting the computer-based MBA entrance exam, gave a presentation to the IIM directors and members of the CAT committee in Mumbai. The presentation was essentially about data from CCTV recordings and computer logs to know the magnitude of glitches. However, the officials refused to say whether any conclusion was reached on the 10-day test that had to be extended by one-day. "The important thing is that, we now have the data. We will analyze it and then take a decision (on whether re-test would be held in the old format). It is too early to comment on anything else," said IIM-B Director Pankaj Chandra.
The Mumbai huddle is seen as a preparatory exercise before the crucial MHRD meeting scheduled for Wednesday. It may be mentioned here while the directors of IIM-Ahmedabad and IIM-Bangalore are not in favour of scrapping the test, the heads of other five IIMs prefer a re-test. With doubts raised over the fairness of the test, there is a consensus among other IIMs (except IIM-A and B) that a re-test would silence all critics. "This is not to say that it is the end of road for computer-based tests. This, being the first year, we faced a lot of hurdles. But we see a lot of gains in the new format. So, next year, we would be better prepared," said an IIM Professor.
It is feared that a re-test may throw the entire academic schedule haywire. If the IIMs decide to hold the test in the old format this year, the CAT organizers would take at least two more months to accommodate 2.41 lakh candidates at various colleges and institutes across the country. The admission process would also be delayed, leaving lesser time for the 2010-11 academic year.
The first demand for scrapping the online exam came from the coaching centres on the fifth day. The trainers form a prominent stakeholder, as close to two lakh candidates take tutorials for the career-defining exam that opens doors to seven IIMs and over 150 B-schools. Apart from the technical glitches, the trainers said, questions were repeated handing out an unfair advantage to those taking the test in the later slots.
Reader's comments (20)
1: This is really bad on the part of IIMs &
the conducting agency PROMETRIC.Even the
management would have gone for TRIAL
demonstration before it was really
implemented for the Original exams ..!
It is not just the wastage of resources but also creating mental tension to many MBA aspirants :(
[ No other state exam are conducting & facing such problems ]
It would be better if proper measures are taken by taking the feedback of students making an online survey before conducting these exams ... Afer all, these are to be facilitating one not frightening one.
Hope atleast by this time management would realise its mistake & rectify to compensate the agony of the students ..
It is not just the wastage of resources but also creating mental tension to many MBA aspirants :(
[ No other state exam are conducting & facing such problems ]
It would be better if proper measures are taken by taking the feedback of students making an online survey before conducting these exams ... Afer all, these are to be facilitating one not frightening one.
Hope atleast by this time management would realise its mistake & rectify to compensate the agony of the students ..
Posted by: Rahul kethavath - 15 Dec, 2009
2: Guys this is really in justise 2 all
deserving candidates who waits 4 this exam
whole year. Dont know y d people from IIM's
wants to play with the future of future
MBA's. If they r nt sure abt d technology
then in that case hw cn they go ahead. If
they wants 2 condust re-test then this is
really bullshit + time wastage + energy waste
etc. As taking online test is not new so they
must d knowing d merits & demerits of
conducting such exam then hw can they do
this.
Posted by: Mani Agarwal - 15 Dec, 2009
3: if IIMs are in a mood of doing a re test that
too a paper pencil one i think there there
will be no change except the no. of students.
The herd which had around 2.41 lacs aspirants
would reduce to some 0.41 lacs.... how can
any one write a competitive exam like CAT
twice in the same year in a span of 2
months....... doesn't that sound a little
weird....
Posted by: sunil kumar singh - 14 Dec, 2009
4: this year CAT was really unfair.....guyz can
u believe tat a friend of mine had a question
TWICE in his paper...this is ridiculous
.....this is not the type of exam we were
awaiting for nearly a year....the IIMS just
dont look bothered..about the students career
they can't play with it....its not only
prometric which is to be blamed its also the
IIMS if they can't prepare 20 different sets
of paper on what bases are they being
fair.....i juzt dont understand what r they
waiting for .....y havnt they still announced
the tentative dates for the re-test.....and
could u believe they are giving reasons for
this hesitant behavior ,that it will be a
time consuming process to again allot
colleges for the students and it will delay
the academic session wat the
hell............so just becoz of this reason
the candidates who appeared this year leaving
their jobs ...etc...with loads and loads of
hopes should forget their dream of
IIM'S....IIM authority must conduct a re-test
....they just can't thwart us this way
Posted by: tanushree baral - 14 Dec, 2009
5: Please, never think of ever going back to
paper and pencil mode. That will be a
retrograde step. Any such change, that too at
such a giant scale, is bound to create
problems in the begining. Learn from the
mistakes and shortcomings and improve. Just
think of Railway reservations of yesteryears
or the ballot boxes in stead of EVMs.
Posted by: Tarun Kumar - 14 Dec, 2009
6: iims can't simply ignore the fact that it is
an exam..not any kind of mock test..it seems
that from their point of view only taking and
completing the exam all that matters.they
even dont think that it is such a exam that
students are under extreme pressure and very
minute factors can affect student's
performance.what ever normalisation they will
do,they cant just make this exam fair.they
simply cant compare this test equivalent to
gmat/gre because they are not computer based
test but computer adaptive.cat 2009 is a
scam..this time hrd minister must force a
retest.
Posted by: bhagabat - 14 Dec, 2009
7: Well, the IIM not arranged the Online test
properly, I mean the testing of application
was not done properly.
Always Indian government looking for low cost budget application, instead of standard developed application.
I seen many government applications which are very bad in performance. take an example for irctc web site it is very slow.
I want they should use latest technology to develop the important applications like CAT or other types they should not relay on Budget they should see the quality. look for US government websites the best quality web sites available and they are very much secured one. They never concentrated on budget they given the importance on Quality...
Regards,
Auradi'sWorld
Always Indian government looking for low cost budget application, instead of standard developed application.
I seen many government applications which are very bad in performance. take an example for irctc web site it is very slow.
I want they should use latest technology to develop the important applications like CAT or other types they should not relay on Budget they should see the quality. look for US government websites the best quality web sites available and they are very much secured one. They never concentrated on budget they given the importance on Quality...
Regards,
Auradi'sWorld
Posted by: Shivakumar Auradi - 14 Dec, 2009
8: Well its nice that the officials of the top
management colleges of our country have taken
a really awesome decision to make CAT paper
online from now. But the way they are doing
the things or the way the things are going is
not good. Can we take the risk that deserving
candidates should underperform due to their
fear of this behavior of servers viruses slow
systems and all that? I think we cant. Cat09
was scheduled for 10 days with 2 slots per
day. It simply means 20 question papers and
20X60=1200 questions.
Wow. For anyone it could be a surprise that there can be possibilties of collecting 1200 questions of CAT level exam totally unique or IIMs are proving themselves that yeah we can do that.
But if still IIMs are saying that we have done the job and let it happen. And we are the best whatever be the problem and even in the case of thier bad examination procedure.
Then nobody is going to suffer other than our own country n IIMs and in atlast we mango people. CAT09 level was so stupid that i guess many of the aspirants must have perform
below their true potential.
But i think they should take a retest and that too a pencil paper test.
Hoping for some good decision by the IIMs and also for the good luck for CAT10 coz i am taking next year exam.
Wow. For anyone it could be a surprise that there can be possibilties of collecting 1200 questions of CAT level exam totally unique or IIMs are proving themselves that yeah we can do that.
But if still IIMs are saying that we have done the job and let it happen. And we are the best whatever be the problem and even in the case of thier bad examination procedure.
Then nobody is going to suffer other than our own country n IIMs and in atlast we mango people. CAT09 level was so stupid that i guess many of the aspirants must have perform
below their true potential.
But i think they should take a retest and that too a pencil paper test.
Hoping for some good decision by the IIMs and also for the good luck for CAT10 coz i am taking next year exam.
Posted by: Harpreet Dhiman - 14 Dec, 2009
9: Well, we students can see everything clearly
that not only the technical glitches but also
students getting extra time as the system
hanged, questions being repeated in different
slots(frm previous yrs CAT paper as well),
disturbances during the exam and hours &
hours of delay in starting the exam are some
of the very strong grounds on which
evaluating all the students will be
completely unfair and biased decision.
Some of them who have been benefitted from this debacle are sure in favour of not conducting a retest but now its completely IIMs take to decide and come up with a fair decision !
We all students are wating for their decision with a ray of hope.
Some of them who have been benefitted from this debacle are sure in favour of not conducting a retest but now its completely IIMs take to decide and come up with a fair decision !
We all students are wating for their decision with a ray of hope.
Posted by: Vrinda - 14 Dec, 2009
10: First of all a note to all those who are
drawing comparisons with GRE. the GRE can
hardly be called a test of aptitude. The sole
intention of the test is to test for a
minimum level of aptitude for entry into US
universities. The CAT on the other hand
cannot be held on the lines of the GRE.
Repetition of questions is an absolute no -
no when it comes to the IIM CAT. All those
who try to bail out the IIMs by saying that
since the test was held for the first time on
a computer based format forget or may be
ignore two important things.
1) this is not the first time prometric is conducting a computer based test. so they should have been better prepared. Isn't it a part of Prometric's drive to check whether all the systems have been scanned instead of giving out lame excuses such as virus attacks?
2) secondly, students spend an entire year preparing for the IIM CAT. What to the IIMs is an yearly exercise, is a once in a life time opportunity for candidates who cannot be made scapegoats.
Back to the paper - pencil test till IIMs guarantee a fool proof arrangement. Its time they applied a few of their own management lessons!
1) this is not the first time prometric is conducting a computer based test. so they should have been better prepared. Isn't it a part of Prometric's drive to check whether all the systems have been scanned instead of giving out lame excuses such as virus attacks?
2) secondly, students spend an entire year preparing for the IIM CAT. What to the IIMs is an yearly exercise, is a once in a life time opportunity for candidates who cannot be made scapegoats.
Back to the paper - pencil test till IIMs guarantee a fool proof arrangement. Its time they applied a few of their own management lessons!
Posted by: Rohit Kshirsagar - 14 Dec, 2009
11: IIM\'s - Shame Shame.
Posted by: Prashant - 14 Dec, 2009
12: Well this year's CAT exam has seen many
problems from server crash to virus attack.
But this all things happens when we do
something so big the 1st time. You can't
expect to get everything right in the 1st
attempt. In my opinion this itself gives us a
managements lesson, saying that even the
IIM's can fail at managing thing.
But lets not target the failure anymore. Instead of being critics, lets suggest some ways to get the things right as we all are aspiring to be into one of the Premiered Institution of the country.
Rather than going for a complete retest and disturbing the academic schedule for the year 2010-2011, Prometric can provide details of the students who have suufered problems because of this errors and given permission for retest with new questions. This can save a lot of time and efforts.
Online exams are already a success with GRE and similar types of exams. So why can't the IIM's go for the same.
But lets not target the failure anymore. Instead of being critics, lets suggest some ways to get the things right as we all are aspiring to be into one of the Premiered Institution of the country.
Rather than going for a complete retest and disturbing the academic schedule for the year 2010-2011, Prometric can provide details of the students who have suufered problems because of this errors and given permission for retest with new questions. This can save a lot of time and efforts.
Online exams are already a success with GRE and similar types of exams. So why can't the IIM's go for the same.
Posted by: Abhishek Sharma - 14 Dec, 2009

13:ya u r correct m agree wit u but
dey(Prometric) have not prepared for dis
exam. 1st dey have 2 checked all d labs
whether all d computer r workin properly or
not, dey hav bakup or not.....So many labs r
nt perfect for conductin dis exam( No AC,
power,slow ......)
Its k wat ever s hapend s past..nw b ready for nxt..hope for best..........
Its k wat ever s hapend s past..nw b ready for nxt..hope for best..........
Pankaj replied to: Abhishek Sharma
post - 14 Dec, 2009
post - 14 Dec, 2009
14: Guyz I believe that their the intent was
right but the implementtaion failed
miserably.
Technical issues apart, as an aspirant repition of questions should have been the last thing expected of IIMs.
Are they telling the world that they cant prepare 20 tests having unique questions. For me this is the most disappointing part. We can sure blame prometric for technical glitches but even from the Exam content preparation's front I think IIMs were ridiculously underprepared.
With due respect seeking a retest this year..
Technical issues apart, as an aspirant repition of questions should have been the last thing expected of IIMs.
Are they telling the world that they cant prepare 20 tests having unique questions. For me this is the most disappointing part. We can sure blame prometric for technical glitches but even from the Exam content preparation's front I think IIMs were ridiculously underprepared.
With due respect seeking a retest this year..
Posted by: Pushkar - 13 Dec, 2009

15:i m totally agree with ur point of
view...more to that i want to raise one more
issue... the standard of questions being
asked.
CAT was known for its logical questions and tricky answers.
this year question were too easy. i dont know what happened to their level. also 60 question in 135 minutes...what quality of a student they were looking for.
they must take RETEST. and need not worry about session being late.
CAT was known for its logical questions and tricky answers.
this year question were too easy. i dont know what happened to their level. also 60 question in 135 minutes...what quality of a student they were looking for.
they must take RETEST. and need not worry about session being late.
prasoon replied to: Pushkar
post - 14 Dec, 2009
post - 14 Dec, 2009
16: This is an mistake that could have been
easily avoided if the IIM'S should by the
decision and used the talent to its full
potential.
IIM'S stand for the best of this country's talent,being a former IIM aspirant myself and a entrepreneur now I held IIM'S in high regard. But more importantly everyone must accept that this is one of the biggest blunders in management coming from the guys who teach management to the country. What happened to planning, design and maintenance, everyone knew what needs to be before? everyone had Data from past CAT's ,any person with little know how on servers would know the capacity needed for such an resource intensive task. Facebook dishes out Images for 335 million people everyday. So the technology is here and IIM'S just didn't do it the right way their technology wing failed miserably and the idea in itself is not a bad one.
Someone at a particular point of time had to take risks.Those who blame this move are those who never act on anything.IIM'S are moving in the right direction and all I ask is to find the right people to do the job.
IIM'S stand for the best of this country's talent,being a former IIM aspirant myself and a entrepreneur now I held IIM'S in high regard. But more importantly everyone must accept that this is one of the biggest blunders in management coming from the guys who teach management to the country. What happened to planning, design and maintenance, everyone knew what needs to be before? everyone had Data from past CAT's ,any person with little know how on servers would know the capacity needed for such an resource intensive task. Facebook dishes out Images for 335 million people everyday. So the technology is here and IIM'S just didn't do it the right way their technology wing failed miserably and the idea in itself is not a bad one.
Someone at a particular point of time had to take risks.Those who blame this move are those who never act on anything.IIM'S are moving in the right direction and all I ask is to find the right people to do the job.
Posted by: Arulprakash Ravindran - 13 Dec, 2009
17: guys after all man made machine throws some
serious loop hole and this is not happen all
in our country . . it happens everywhere . .
.
Posted by: ca kartik pandya - 13 Dec, 2009
18: Premier institutes like IIMs have maintained
their standards and reputation by the
contribution of students and not the
faculties. The profesors and the staffs
performance have always been under scrutiny
and have often dissapointed all by their
actions. The online test is another example
of the fiasco specially other indian
institute has been conducting successfullly
such online tests.
Posted by: Anil Prasad - 13 Dec, 2009
19: even though a new way should always be taken
when the world is taking a leap..but IIM 'S
should have been more authentic on taking
such hasty decisions to go on-line..the real
calibre of a students come from writing a
paper based test, seeing the imaginary world
of computers and its fantasy i would feel
that this time it should be online taking the
time factor into consideration, next time
onwards it should be paper based as the iim's
would only take nearly 1600-1700 students per
year why this great surfing?
Posted by: intelpentium - 13 Dec, 2009

20:it is really amazing and in fact shocking
that the IIMS even after knowing that so much
has happened( like server failures, students
getting more time because of power cuts,
questions being repeated and hence many
students knowing many questions from before,
cheating at many centers and what not) during
the online test that they held, they are
planning to continue with this. I dont
understand how are they planning to maintain
the fairness
of the exam if they conduct exams like this.
of the exam if they conduct exams like this.
ajay replied to: intelpentium
post - 14 Dec, 2009
post - 14 Dec, 2009
Disclaimer
Messages posted on this Web site under the `Comments' area are solely the opinions of those who have posted them and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd or its site www.siliconindia.com. Gossip, mud slinging and malicious attacks on individuals and organizations are strictly prohibited. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd can not be held responsible for errors or omissions in content, nor for the authenticity of the user/company name or email addresses associated with posted messages. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd reserves the right to edit or remove messages containing inappropriate language or any other material that could be construed as libelous, potentially libelous,
or otherwise offensive or inappropriate.Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd do not endorse the products and services or any other offerings mentioned in these messages.
Recent posts from Career news
- The Joy of Rain
- New tech improves voice clarity on mobile
- Apple set to launch smaller, lighter iPod Nano
- Deutsche Bank to move work form Infosys BPO
- For Sale: Your Personal Data!
- Faster and simpler Chrome 6 out now
- Transformation techniques
- Harness the Power of Collaboration
- Post Graduation, NO JOB?? Planning an MBA!
- The life that is called Kolkata
- Is Hari Prasad an ethical hacker and be set free?
- No visa for firms hiring less than 50 percent Americans
- Gill attacks Premji's comment on CWG
- Indian-origin student questions Darwin's theory
- Highest paid jobs for Freshers: R&D, IT jobs rank 2nd
- Farmers to save Rs. 600 Crore courtesy mobile broadband
- Should we expect another fiasco in CAT?
- No promotions,half of the Indians pros give it a quit
- Capacitor with 'onion layer tech' to power gadgets
- Tips to deal with politics at workplace


