Raju's confession - whistle blower's act
By
siliconindia news bureau
New Delhi: The confession of B Ramalinga Raju, the disgraced founder of Satyam, which unfolded as the biggest corporate scandal, was not prompted by his conscience rather a whistle blower's action. An email of a person, who claimed to be a former Satyam executive, to one of the firm's board members ignited a chain of events that led to the confession.
.jpg)
"The first email of Abraham was written to the company's independent director Krishna G Palepu on December 18, 2008 that Satyam did not have any liquid assets. He also maintained that the fact could be independently verified from its banks," an official, who is privy to the confidential SFIO report told The Economic Times. The findings are based on a 14,000-page report submitted by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) to the government earlier this week. The SFIO concluded the Satyam scandal to be Rs.7,333 crore as of end-September last year. Raju's revelations was the result of a actions of a person who leaped into the firm's scam using a pseudonym as Jose Abraham and asserted his involvement in Satyam's contracts with the World Bank. The email was sent a day after Mr Raju was forced to abort Satyam's plans to buy two companies linked to his family, Maytas Infra and Maytas Properties, after it ran into a storm of investor protest.
The revelations immediately spread among the Satyam's former board membersM Rammohan Rao, VS Raju , TR Prasad and Satyam's statutory auditor S Gopalakrishnan of Price Waterhouse. A copy of the email was also sent to B Ramalinga Raju, who had started receving calls from members of the board's audit committee, but did not respond to any of them. The SFIO report also reveals that these speculations led Raju to hold meetings with company's then CFO and vice-president for finance G Ramakrishna, between last December 25 and January 7 to work out a plan to hide the fraud. Failing to find a way out and concerned that he might be caught by capital market regulator SEBI and the U.S. Securities Exchange Commission (SEC), Raju issued his sensational confession.
According to the investigation report, the falsification of the company's accounts began in the financial year 2001-02 after there was an informal meeting between Ramalinga Raju, his brother Rama Raju and Srinivas, apart from the company's vice-president finance G Ramakrishna. This report will form the foundation for initiation of a criminal action against Ramalinga Raju, Rama Raju, Vadlamani Srinivas, Price Waterhouse officials S Gopalakrishnan and Srinivas Talluri, and two other company executives , senior manager finance D Venkatapathy Raju and finance manager C Srisailan.
.jpg)
"The first email of Abraham was written to the company's independent director Krishna G Palepu on December 18, 2008 that Satyam did not have any liquid assets. He also maintained that the fact could be independently verified from its banks," an official, who is privy to the confidential SFIO report told The Economic Times. The findings are based on a 14,000-page report submitted by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) to the government earlier this week. The SFIO concluded the Satyam scandal to be Rs.7,333 crore as of end-September last year. Raju's revelations was the result of a actions of a person who leaped into the firm's scam using a pseudonym as Jose Abraham and asserted his involvement in Satyam's contracts with the World Bank. The email was sent a day after Mr Raju was forced to abort Satyam's plans to buy two companies linked to his family, Maytas Infra and Maytas Properties, after it ran into a storm of investor protest.
The revelations immediately spread among the Satyam's former board membersM Rammohan Rao, VS Raju , TR Prasad and Satyam's statutory auditor S Gopalakrishnan of Price Waterhouse. A copy of the email was also sent to B Ramalinga Raju, who had started receving calls from members of the board's audit committee, but did not respond to any of them. The SFIO report also reveals that these speculations led Raju to hold meetings with company's then CFO and vice-president for finance G Ramakrishna, between last December 25 and January 7 to work out a plan to hide the fraud. Failing to find a way out and concerned that he might be caught by capital market regulator SEBI and the U.S. Securities Exchange Commission (SEC), Raju issued his sensational confession.
According to the investigation report, the falsification of the company's accounts began in the financial year 2001-02 after there was an informal meeting between Ramalinga Raju, his brother Rama Raju and Srinivas, apart from the company's vice-president finance G Ramakrishna. This report will form the foundation for initiation of a criminal action against Ramalinga Raju, Rama Raju, Vadlamani Srinivas, Price Waterhouse officials S Gopalakrishnan and Srinivas Talluri, and two other company executives , senior manager finance D Venkatapathy Raju and finance manager C Srisailan.
Reader's comments(22)
1: At least Raju confessed may be out of fear
once it comes in the open it willdamage his
image more severely. But what about the
politicians and bureaucrats who have been
actively and passivley helping him since it
is not possible for him alone to carry it out
all alone. When some one will blow the
whistle on them.
Posted by: Munish - 21 Apr, 2009
3: I don't understand why we Indians get so
excited when every couple of years such
Harshad Mehtas and Rajus are made scapegoats.
I don't say they are not culprits. They are
just the tips of the ice-bergs. Why do we
want to ignore the political and corporate
mafias behind such people. Without their
knowledge and support such hige scams cannot
take place.
Would every one not want to question Congress Party which has ensured that exactly before Ballot starts, they got so much revealed from Raju, sold Satyam to TechMahindra so that they can portray a clean picture of theirs both on national and state level(AP and center both place Congress is in power) and fool even literate but innocent voters...
Even it is not easy to gulp down such huge amount alone by Raju and few of his aides.
Would anybody want to think about this?
Would every one not want to question Congress Party which has ensured that exactly before Ballot starts, they got so much revealed from Raju, sold Satyam to TechMahindra so that they can portray a clean picture of theirs both on national and state level(AP and center both place Congress is in power) and fool even literate but innocent voters...
Even it is not easy to gulp down such huge amount alone by Raju and few of his aides.
Would anybody want to think about this?
Posted by: GFS - 17 Apr, 2009

4:Its ok he accepted. Raju will face the music,
But here why most of the people who are
definitely related with Active politics
trying to potray as Congress curruption lead
this. They are trying to pose as TDP or some
other BJP are Honest ones what foolish thing.
Ramalinga Raju had Floated lot of Funds to
TDP & BJP parties during 1999-2004.
Ramalinga raju intiated thsi frod In 2001 as
the report here says. So Frends No Political
party nor Politician are exceptional
Abhee replied to: GFS
post - 08 May, 2009
post - 08 May, 2009
5: I don't understand why we Indians get so
excited when every couple of years such
Harshad Mehtas and Rajus are made scapegoats.
I don't say they are not culprits. They are
just the tips of the ice-bergs. Why don't we
want to ignore the political and corporate
mafias behind such people. Without their
knowledge and support such hige scams cannot
take place.
Would every not want to question Congress which has ensured that exactly before Ballot starts, they got so much revealed from Raju, sold Satyam to TechMahindra so that they can portray a clean picture of theirs both on national and state level(AP and center both place Congress is in power).
Even it is not easy to gulp down such huge amount alone by Raju and few of his aides.
Would anybody want to think about this?
Would every not want to question Congress which has ensured that exactly before Ballot starts, they got so much revealed from Raju, sold Satyam to TechMahindra so that they can portray a clean picture of theirs both on national and state level(AP and center both place Congress is in power).
Even it is not easy to gulp down such huge amount alone by Raju and few of his aides.
Would anybody want to think about this?
Posted by: G S - 17 Apr, 2009
6: Good that Whistle Blowers are successful in
making the justice system work in India. The
hypocrats of the world, US, preach honesty
but practise hardly. A whistle blower would
have been shutdown for good in US, if they
tried to blow on old boys network consisting
of corrupt government officials and
contractors. We tried to bring out the facts
on Agriculture and IRS, but were got badly
hampered and shutdown for any future
business. I am glad that India responded
better than a country who preaches honesty
but practises mafias running their
government.
Posted by: John X. - 17 Apr, 2009
7: Madoff tried to race and overtake a bull
market. He failed when the market turned
around unexpectedly. That is a strategy that
is understandable and its failure is
understandable too. It was a gamble that
failed - not a rip off.
What was Raju all about? Was he into IT? or was he leveraging his assets to go someplace? if so where?
There is more to this than meets the eye. This being India lets call in the torturers. Raju on the rack will probably spill the beans. Long live Kautilya!
What was Raju all about? Was he into IT? or was he leveraging his assets to go someplace? if so where?
There is more to this than meets the eye. This being India lets call in the torturers. Raju on the rack will probably spill the beans. Long live Kautilya!
Posted by: crazyoldmansl - 17 Apr, 2009
8: What Raju did is definitely wrong thing. If
initially he faked his account then he should
have complete confidence, vision that he
would recover this difference with his
profit. But he continued to fake, and present
troublt created. If we compare this fraud
with Madoff\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'s, its different.
Madoff\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'s fraud was related to
cheating common man to wealthier. Then many
people were duped. But Raju duped no common
man. In another word, he cheated wealthier or
whole economy. We need to see what law says
which is the big sin- to cheat so many (poor
+ rich) people or to cheat economy.
Posted by: vidyasagar - 17 Apr, 2009
9: The crime is one should not be caught in the
act. The mega rich invariably have many
skeletons hidden away. Maddoff in New York to
Raju in Hyderabad belong to the same class as
those who got caught but there are many times
more who got away covering their tracks. But
these are the exceptional persons who while
they got benefited in turn benefited the
society too, creating a valuable asset like
Satyam, in case of Raju.But in case of
Maddoff it is a pure ripoff, nothing is
left.Honesty is a human value more insisted
upon by the ruler for his subjects, but not
as much observed by the ruler himself. Raju
is punished for being caught, else in another
5 years he would have been presented with
Bharat Ratna. Human society has evolved with
visible and invisible value systems and the
same ancient jungle law continues to prevail.
The strong till they fall in disgrace rule
the roost.
Posted by: B Rajaram - 17 Apr, 2009
10: Nice informative post detailing the facts of
the case. However, the language and style
leaves a bad taste in the mouth. Not becoming
of a major portal at all.
Posted by: Suresh Mangaladurai - 17 Apr, 2009
11: There have been many scandals across the
world & Satyam has become one of them
now. Raju might have done for 7 years for
around 7500 Crs. But let us accept the fact
that, we are facing such frauds in the
politicals system since freedom. Neither we
have any personal will nor any political will
to counter this. I urge here to take this
forward to well known honest persons like Dr
Abdul Kalam Ji, Mr Ratan Tata ji , Mr
Narayana Murthy ji. Let us all have a
combine request to them to step in and try to
wash the dust in the system
Posted by: Chandra Sekhar - 17 Apr, 2009
12: Every thief has his day.Like the Telgi Scam,
Satyam Scam was just like a pandora box
hidden,when it was opened evryhting was
out.
Its really very disgraced to know about the largest scam in the corporate world.
Mr Raju never wanted to disclose everything what he had done rather involed many more worms who are still now hidden in the satyam scandal
Its really very disgraced to know about the largest scam in the corporate world.
Mr Raju never wanted to disclose everything what he had done rather involed many more worms who are still now hidden in the satyam scandal
Posted by: Anupam Rout - 17 Apr, 2009
13: with this new information (about what led to
the confession)the existing tarnished image
of yesterday's corporate honcho also gets
shattered.
Posted by: kansel - 17 Apr, 2009
14: This proves the fact that there are other
worms in Satyam Can, who are sitting well
entrenched. It is still suproising how the
members of the top management were not aware
of the financial fraud as it was being
committed. The CBI should also look into the
comlicity of other members of the management
tea, especially those loyal cronies to whom
the fraudster Raju gave a clean chit. If the
CBI delves deeper it is sure to find the
silence money that was being paid out to
these people.
Posted by: Rajesh - 16 Apr, 2009
15: Atleast there was some consideration and
little sympathy that he had the guts to
confess such a huge fraud.. now it shows that
it was no guts rather a well-thought plan..
people who showed some concern for Raju will
surely have no words now..
Posted by: pammi - 16 Apr, 2009

16:I totally go with Pammi. if he had guts he
would have confessed or revealed the truth 8
years back only.
Anjali replied to: pammi
post - 16 Apr, 2009
post - 16 Apr, 2009

17: If he had the guts, he neednt have confessed.
He would not have wronged in the first place!
tpp replied to: Anjali
post - 17 Apr, 2009
post - 17 Apr, 2009

18: U tell me 1 thing Anjali...Is it only Satyam
who has done this siphoning ?Other companies
also carries on this system.but they dont get
caught...Its Raju's misfortune..He committed
the thing and confessed...a great gesture.
Subhasis replied to: Anjali
post - 17 Apr, 2009
post - 17 Apr, 2009

19: r u okay dude.. if the other person wouldn't
have interrupted.. your so-called good
gestured Raju would have never confessed. he
knew if he donot confess then it would be out
in no time and then the charges will be more.
amanat replied to: Subhasis
post - 17 Apr, 2009
post - 17 Apr, 2009

20: Dear Subhashish
Somebody siphons off lakhs of Rupees from your personal bank account and tenders an apology, will you still say its a great gesture ?!
What a joke ! A fraud is a fraud. For heaven's sake please dont glorify them.
Somebody siphons off lakhs of Rupees from your personal bank account and tenders an apology, will you still say its a great gesture ?!
What a joke ! A fraud is a fraud. For heaven's sake please dont glorify them.
Ramandeep Singh replied to: Subhasis
post - 17 Apr, 2009
post - 17 Apr, 2009

21: Hi Subhasis
Let us not celebrate wrong people. It is not is misfortune that he has been caught. He is suffering for his misdeeds. Let us all (the people)ensure that whoever do misdeeds be caught and punished. Let they be Corporate Honchos, Politicians, Bureaucrats or even people from Lower working ranks such as Clerks, Peons in the Government sector. That is the only way we can ensure a good India for the future generations
Let us not celebrate wrong people. It is not is misfortune that he has been caught. He is suffering for his misdeeds. Let us all (the people)ensure that whoever do misdeeds be caught and punished. Let they be Corporate Honchos, Politicians, Bureaucrats or even people from Lower working ranks such as Clerks, Peons in the Government sector. That is the only way we can ensure a good India for the future generations
Kanthan replied to: Subhasis
post - 17 Apr, 2009
post - 17 Apr, 2009
Disclaimer
Messages posted on this Web site under the `Comments' area are solely the opinions of those who have posted them and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd or its site www.siliconindia.com. Gossip, mud slinging and malicious attacks on individuals and organizations are strictly prohibited. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd can not be held responsible for errors or omissions in content, nor for the authenticity of the user/company name or email addresses associated with posted messages. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd reserves the right to edit or remove messages containing inappropriate language or any other material that could be construed as libelous, potentially libelous,
or otherwise offensive or inappropriate.Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd do not endorse the products and services or any other offerings mentioned in these messages.
- Indian utility will buy 150,000 water meters
- IBM unveils new POWER7 systems
- CA extends support for Open Source
- Now pay credit card dues as a loan
- MBAs line up for jobs in healthcare
- Yes Bank to deploy Servion's IVR
- Sony to unveil in-box wireless technology
- GPS based application struggling to expand
- Hindustan Copper shares rise 10 percent
- AB Minacs buys tech solutions firm Radifinity
- Auto driver turns web entrepreneur
- Students make electric appliances operable via sms
- Change management: BSNL employees to PM
- An IITian lights 10,000 homes in rural Bihar
- Indians are over committed, reluctant to differ
- Indian entrepreneurs sign deals like housewives
- China 5th, India nowhere in top 15 UN patent filings
- Biggies back with bonuses, startups suffer
- Over 15,000 NRI resumes lying with Indian HR firms
- Obama's invitation to 'Bihar's Rickshaw Man'






