Karnataka BJP leaders toe Yeddyurappa's line on 'pub culture'
By
IANS
| |
Bangalore: The daughter might have differed with her father, but Karnataka Chief Minister B.S. Yeddyurappa's party colleagues seem to toe his line as far as disallowing "pub culture" in the state is concerned.
The chief minister had Wednesday told media that he won't "allow" pub culture to flourish in Karnataka even though he termed the attack on women at a Mangalore pub "unfortunate". But one of his daughters, Umadevi, disagreed with her father views.
In an interview with a leading national English daily Wednesday, Umadevi (37), the founder of Candor Business Solutions Pvt Ltd, a BPO based in Bangalore, opposed Yeddyurappa's views and said: "It's for women to decide if they would like to visit pubs or any other public place, and the government, politicians or outfits like Sri Rama Sene cannot restrict their movements."
As the father-daughter differences turned into a controversy, top Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders in the state followed the chief minister's view on the issue.
State Home Minister V.S. Acharya told IANS that pub culture increases crime and violence and needs to have restrictions.
"There should be some amount of control on the pubs by the government to avoid any untoward incident. The chief minister is right in his view," said Acharya.
BJP state chief D.V. Sadanand Gowda said: "Our party is in favour of curbing pub culture as it makes intoxication fashionable leading to many incidents of misbehaviour. Pub culture should be tackled in an appropriate way, as the youth of today just don't see the damage they are doing to themselves and the society."
Senior BJP leader and MP Ananth Kumar preferred not to make any statement on the matter.
"There is nothing to say on the issue. We have several other work to deal with," said Kumar.
Sources at the chief minister's office told IANS that Umadevi had been misquoted by the newspaper. Umadevi, however, remained unavailable for comment Friday to clarify her view.
Yeddyurappa's remark on 'pub culture' came close on the heels of a national outrage against the BJP government for showing leniency in taking action against members of Sri Rama Sene, a self-styled moral group who attacked a group of young women in a pub in Mangalore Saturday.
Reacting to the chief minister's comment on disallowing pub culture in Bangalore, Biocon chairperson Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw said that Yeddyurappa's view was totally retrograde.
"Bangalore has a healthy pub culture and going to a pub is not a crime. Moreover, pubs like restaurants are also safe for their visitors. Curtailment on visiting pubs is denying a person his or her basic right. The government should rather end corruption, the greatest vice of the society, instead of stopping people from going to pubs," she said.
The chief minister had Wednesday told media that he won't "allow" pub culture to flourish in Karnataka even though he termed the attack on women at a Mangalore pub "unfortunate". But one of his daughters, Umadevi, disagreed with her father views.
In an interview with a leading national English daily Wednesday, Umadevi (37), the founder of Candor Business Solutions Pvt Ltd, a BPO based in Bangalore, opposed Yeddyurappa's views and said: "It's for women to decide if they would like to visit pubs or any other public place, and the government, politicians or outfits like Sri Rama Sene cannot restrict their movements."
As the father-daughter differences turned into a controversy, top Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leaders in the state followed the chief minister's view on the issue.
State Home Minister V.S. Acharya told IANS that pub culture increases crime and violence and needs to have restrictions.
"There should be some amount of control on the pubs by the government to avoid any untoward incident. The chief minister is right in his view," said Acharya.
BJP state chief D.V. Sadanand Gowda said: "Our party is in favour of curbing pub culture as it makes intoxication fashionable leading to many incidents of misbehaviour. Pub culture should be tackled in an appropriate way, as the youth of today just don't see the damage they are doing to themselves and the society."
Senior BJP leader and MP Ananth Kumar preferred not to make any statement on the matter.
"There is nothing to say on the issue. We have several other work to deal with," said Kumar.
Sources at the chief minister's office told IANS that Umadevi had been misquoted by the newspaper. Umadevi, however, remained unavailable for comment Friday to clarify her view.
Yeddyurappa's remark on 'pub culture' came close on the heels of a national outrage against the BJP government for showing leniency in taking action against members of Sri Rama Sene, a self-styled moral group who attacked a group of young women in a pub in Mangalore Saturday.
Reacting to the chief minister's comment on disallowing pub culture in Bangalore, Biocon chairperson Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw said that Yeddyurappa's view was totally retrograde.
"Bangalore has a healthy pub culture and going to a pub is not a crime. Moreover, pubs like restaurants are also safe for their visitors. Curtailment on visiting pubs is denying a person his or her basic right. The government should rather end corruption, the greatest vice of the society, instead of stopping people from going to pubs," she said.
Reader's comments(4)
1: Drinking is "western culture"? Who are these
idiots? Drinking has been in India for
centuries. What is this talk about pubs? Are
bars where hooligans like the Ram Sene people
drink any better? Pubs are much safer in
comparison to bars simply because it is
filled with people who are educated and
cultured. Who are these people to preach
morality? They believe in something, let them
live it. They cannot come out and beat up
people who do not believe what they believe.
Stop making india another Talibani nation.
Posted by: Karthik - 31 Jan, 2009
2: Indian political leaders have an unfortunate
knack to muddle issues. They have to
recognize that in a democracy, they are
representatives of people and not rulers.
They have to carry the will of the people as
expressed at the ballot. Again unfortunately,
Indian states do not have or do not follow
referendums. One would expect a political
party to include an initiative as a principle
or as a policy in their election platform and
take it to the people during elections. After
the elections, they may introduce bills and
pass legislation. If approved, the initiative
becomes the law of the land (state). The law
may totally prohibit certain activities or
place certain standards for establishments to
operate under.
Unfortunately, Indian leaders do not speak language (English or mother tongue) well. “Unfortunate’ is not an appropriate word to define a CM’s reaction to violent actions against women (or men) by organized goondas, no matter what God’s name they bear. A CM has a responsibility to uphold the law which grants security to all in a state from organized and unorganized groups and they have to condemn violations and prosecute criminals to the full extent of the law.
Unfortunately, Indian leaders do not speak language (English or mother tongue) well. “Unfortunate’ is not an appropriate word to define a CM’s reaction to violent actions against women (or men) by organized goondas, no matter what God’s name they bear. A CM has a responsibility to uphold the law which grants security to all in a state from organized and unorganized groups and they have to condemn violations and prosecute criminals to the full extent of the law.
Posted by: Som Karamchetty, PHD - 31 Jan, 2009
3: u are must be foolish villager who can just
stare at people having fun.. dont be
desperate doing nothing life.. open up.. see
whats happening outside your village
mr.indian
Posted by: new indian - 30 Jan, 2009
4: Yes, that's what a state must follow, people
will give full support to the government if
it takes action to close down all the pubs in
the state. let's not blindly follow the
western culture....
Posted by: An Indian - 30 Jan, 2009
Disclaimer
Messages posted on this Web site under the `Comments' area are solely the opinions of those who have posted them and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd or its site www.siliconindia.com. Gossip, mud slinging and malicious attacks on individuals and organizations are strictly prohibited. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd can not be held responsible for errors or omissions in content, nor for the authenticity of the user/company name or email addresses associated with posted messages. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd reserves the right to edit or remove messages containing inappropriate language or any other material that could be construed as libelous, potentially libelous,
or otherwise offensive or inappropriate.Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd do not endorse the products and services or any other offerings mentioned in these messages.
Recent posts from news
- Siemens to slash 1,000 jobs
- Xerox comes up with Innovation Hub in India
- IT pros deliberately like to break IT rules
- Character becomes a major hiring factor
- iPhone can be too addictive
- Indian founded Perfios Software raises $2 Million
- Social Networks to give e-mail a run for business
- United Bank of India to list on March 18
- IT index hogs limelight last week
- Hindustan Copper shares soar 19 percent
- 22 yr old Indian to solve cyber crimes @ mouse click
- IIMs' high salary: The true story has a twist
- Will foreign varsities poach IIT, IIM profs?
- Women MPs more successful, qualified than men
- IIM grads opt domestic offers to international ones
- Aircel launches a Qwerty handset for Rs. 2,999
- BSNL's business incurs Rs. 4,963 Crore loss
- Approaching a VC? Here is a checklist
- Employees more loyal now, courtesy slowdown
- Indian-U.S. Prof. wins $500,000 U.S. science award


