Executive Movements   |  General   |  Tech   |  Campus Buzz  
Sign in to your SiliconIndia account
Email:       Password:  
Don't have SiliconIndia account? Sign up     Forgot your password? Reset
    Processing .....please wait..
    The article has been forwarded....
     Some error occured      !!
Forward this news to your friends & colleague
Subject:
Receiver's email:
For more than one recipient, type addresses separated by commas
Your name:
Your email:
Message:
Type the characters you see in the picture
Bosses' misconceptions cripple women's career
By   siliconindia news bureau
Wednesday,18 November 2009, 18:47 hrs
 
Bangalore: According to a new research, women's career gets affected, due to bosses' misconceptions about them being prone to be in conflict between family commitments and workplace responsibilities.

A study in the current issue of the Academy of Management Journal reveals that bosses generally perceive women workers to have more family-work conflict than men, even though this isn't the case. And this belief, mistaken though it is, leads supervisors to take a negative view of women employees' suitability for promotion.



"Managers have a tendency to categorize women as experiencing greater family-work conflict, even after controlling for family responsibilities and women's own perceptions of family-work conflict," conclude the study's Authors, Jenny M. Hoobler, Sandy J. Wayne, and Grace Lemmon of the University of Illinois at Chicago. "Even though female employees actually reported slightly less family-work conflict than their male counterparts, their managers still perceived them as having greater family-work conflict, a perception that had significant implications for women's organizational advancement."

Surprisingly, these perceptual biases held for both male and female managers, both of whom are prone to give credence to stereotypical attributes ascribed to women as responsible for family, which may be seen as incompatible with leadership/managerial positions.

The study's findings, raise concerns about company-sponsored programs that assist employees with managing family-work conflict. Employees who participate in these programs may signal to their managers that they have family demands and need assistance in balancing home and work domains. Participation in these company-sponsored programs may reduce the likelihood that their managers view them as fitting with the job and organization, consequently reducing their promotion opportunities.

The study's findings derive from surveys of 178 employees - 52 managers and 126 subordinates - of a large transportation company, a high-volume, goods-handling organization. In sum, responses of 126 supervisor - subordinate pairs were analyzed. Subordinates were questioned about their family status; demographics; family-work conflict; and whether or not they had been nominated for promotions. Managers provided information on demographics; their perceptions of subordinates' family-work conflict; subordinates' in-role performance; and their job fit, company fit, and promotability.

Whatever subordinates' family situation happens to be and however workers view its relationship to their jobs, the mere fact that one is a woman significantly increases the degree of family-work conflict that one's boss perceived. And that negative perception, the professors found, significantly affected how bosses assessed workers' suitability for their jobs and for employment in the company and ultimately whether they deserved to be promoted.

     
   
Write your comment now


Your Name    Email: 
Type the characters you see in the picture

  Cancel
Reader's comments(37)
1: I have an indifferent view on this topic because lot of things depends upon the oranisational culture..Just on the basis of few oranisation we cannot make a generalised statement on this subject.Further it is a wrong perception that females have to be more balanced in work and family committments.As we have more number of women who are actully very career oriented we cannot make allegations like this on females.Males can also have a similar problem and it actually differs from bosses to bosses that how much empathetic he is towards his employees.Infact women have more stable career graph than men and women have lesser tendency to be a job hopper so ultimately it depends on the interpersonal skills of the bosses that how do they handle their employees' problem.
Posted by: sumi shweta  - 22 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
2: I think this study does not seem to have substance, or too many loopholes.

Also, when you say juggle between home and office work, as far I know these days, women have enough of servants and nannies at home to do the work. I can bet many a dime that working women (sometimes even housewives) nowadays wont wash their clothes, wash vessels, sweep and mop the house or cook. Some women don't know how to make a tea. So what house work are we talking here?

Unlike during my mother's or grandmother's time in Delhi, where women did a lot of home work, they used to be the binding force in the family, keeping everyone bonded and in joint family. Today, a daughter-in-law's first task is to split the family, move to independent home, so that she needn't do all the work, make her husband do all the work or keep servants. I know my friend's homes where men do much more work than women. I have seen this even in households where the woman doesnt work.

So when study say juggle between house and office, they mean `work' at office and `watch' household work being done.
Posted by: MrSingh - 21 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
3: "If a new research, women's career gets affected, due to bosses' misconceptions about them being prone to be in conflict between family commitments and workplace responsibilities"......how is India's current lady president is handling a big responsible and noble job? The bosses should change their misconceptions...Most of the developed countries ladies hold a high positions and still can juggle with family conflict....
Posted by: rev - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
4: It fairly is not a misconception. It definitely is going to affect everyone when the boss wanted the employee to work 12-14 hours a day. Men can withstand it by giving excuses to family. But a child need a mother "at the least".

IT industry in India is squeezing poor resources. Now they think male is better than female, just because male will survive in any sick situations by compromising their family.
Posted by: ithin - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
5: wo o o o o thats what i call a perfect stupid study 178 samples / subjects and u generalized it how idiot u r .
no need to study man , women separately who have / possess ability will come up .
stop publicizing this level of idiot articles.
Posted by: honey - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
6: Honestly, seems like some people really don't have anything better to do than comment on idiotic studies! Firstly, this is the most un-scientific study report that i have ever come across, a sample of 178 and all from the same company? And yet they call it a study and not a schoolboy research project. Secondly, even if this study is genuine, can someone please explain what is the use of expressing your chauvinistic views here or for that matter calling people chauvinists? What matters is how we are in private and not how we pretend to be? Get real everyone, there are indeed issues out there which you and I can and should discuss and try & find a solution to - issues like hunger, homelessness, illiteracy, absence of any medical facilities, the list can go on. Discussing how a manager/supervisor perceives their women employees is a waste of time & energy.

Cheers.
Posted by: Chirodeep - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
7: One cannot believe everything they read. Other studies have proven this study absolutely and totally false. Read the other studies before jumping on this bandwagon as it does not portray the US as it truly is. Since men are at war there are more women now in the workforce than ever and almost as many women are working now than men. Women here have learned to balance work with home, and laws here are in place to help them do that. The study that was conducted had only 178 participants, that\\\\\\\'s no real sampling of the USA.
Posted by: christiefox - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
8: It is not about the family work. It is about the concentration on work. Female employees are very committed to the job and stable, as compared to male employees. But then, don't expect them to do wonders for you. It is never about the family matters. Even males bring their family matters to office in the same way, the females do - Making excuses for leaves. I understand that there are emergencies sometimes, but when it becomes too much, they are just excuses, and not the need.

The problem with the female employees is their extremist behavior. If they are after 1 thing, they will not leave it until that is done. It is good sometimes, but not always. This hinders them to do multi-tasking. Urgency of work means nothing to them. And not all of them are like that. Some of them are really sharp and they know what to do when, and those are the ones, who succeed in their life and make a better career. The extremist ones favor their favorites on the basis of their liking, not the actual work they do. It doesn’t matter if the person is screwing up his work big time, but if that person is good to that female, he is a wonderful employee. This is the reason, female bosses do not succeed the same way, and the male bosses do, in the same kind of environment.

No offenses to anyone here, especially Pradeep. But this is my opinion and anyone over here has the right to put forward his/her opinion.
Posted by: Jas - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
9: One cannot believe everything they read. Other studies have proven this study absolutely and totally false. Read the other studies before jumping on this bandwagon as it does not portray the US as it truly is. Since men are at war there are more women now in the workforce than ever and almost as many women are working now than men. Women here have learned to balance work with home, and laws here are in place to help them do that. The study that was conducted had only 178 participants, that\'s no real sampling of the USA.
Posted by: christiefox - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
10: The footer chosen here looks more general.

To be specific, very few men feel so. Men, who had not shared a balanced, non-gender specific space with women, during his upbringing, would definitely feel so.

Women employee’s have the upper hand with multi tasking abilities.
Most of the time, it’s the insecure feeling of gents, (not only bosses) which acts as hurdle for their carrier growth.
All through my carrier the dedication, quality of work, from women (spinster/married) to their assignments have always been steps higher than us (men).
In reality women switch quite easily between family commitments and professional commitments. Even though it’s a paradigm shift, women can handle it wisely.
The sensitiveness of women, when misinterpreted brings us to such conclusions.
-My personal opinion.
Posted by: ram - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
11: A employee here use to come at office at 11.00 or 11.30.
Leave the office at 6.30 or 7.30. NOT married.
What will be the timing after Marriage?

Male bosses are taken for granted that They should/ Must understand about a women as emoployee Boss should pay same bucks but put extra comfort zone for all females

SO THAT all females can manage their HOME! or their OWN things when they are not yet married.


COming on time and Going On time .. and understanding the importance of TIME as they dont have

is what expected from women



and If this is the case Males bosses can happily arrange comfort zone for them .


The Thing is that Females should argue at home as they have responsibilities at Office as same at office

and resultant will be a combined effect NOT the NULL effect :)


Regards
Sushant Danekar
Posted by: sushant Danekar - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
12:Sushant, then why don't you do the house work? It is your house also isn't it? what you have written is very chauvinistic...
Read the article again... "Even though female employees actually reported slightly less family-work conflict than their male counterparts, their managers still perceived them as having greater family-work conflict, a perception that had significant implications for women's organizational advancement." - third paragraph... dont be biased they are also your own...
 Pradeep replied to: sushant Danekar 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
13: i think india still has high respect for women than west, that could be one reason india continues to be developing country, it doesnt have aggressiveness, may be because of that reason. And west continues to dominates and use us.
Posted by: vin - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
14:I'd be curious as to how the "west dominates and uses you". Words like "using" and "dominates" could have either positive or negative connotation. That needs to be clarified.
 christiefox replied to: vin 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
15: Why india is still being denied a seat at security council at UN, India is a country with half of world population doesnt deserves it.

When india entered globalization as part of agendy of west, so that western companies profits will increase by selling their products in india, do you know what happned? thousand of indians working at indian companies lost their jobs,. No body in world heard that cry. But now for outsourcing so much of noise is created, it is justifiable.
In some europian countries where outsourcing is linked for indian students being denied for scholarships. How fair is that? But still these universities cant live without indian students, they want them to come there and study at their expense, and are treated with a dignity a foreign student doesnt deserve and enduring lot of trouble.
 vinay replied to:  christiefox 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
16: What misconceptions are we talking about? Misconceptions happen to men as it does for women. The source of such conflict may be different, thats all. Ok, here goes, have 3 or 6 months maternity leave (we don't get paternity leave, but juggle between office and hospital for women's care), then they get sick leaves, paid holidays, Saturdays and Sundays, public holidays, festivals, some days late to office because of home problems, kids, PTA meeting, whatever... Is this a misconception or hard fact?

Also, when men do some help at home, women want men to do a work the way they think it should be done! Oh, so u think we men cant do the work? If u want it done yr way, do it yrself. We have brains and skills to do it and complete it the way we want, much efficiently, smarter ways. End result would be the same but we finish it earlier and cleaner that's the only difference.

Also, more than misconceptions, women who reach the top or become a boss, many times become too big for the shoes, abusing, throwing tantrums, etc.

I have seen very few good smiling efficient woman bosses, doing their work and getting work done very nicely and well. In fact most women bosses are selfish too. This is NOT my statement, I have heard women employees hate women bosses, forget about men. On the contrary I have heard of men praising their women bosses (I had 3 women bosses in my 9 year career, 1 was perfect, wish I could work with her again, but 2 others were absolute sh@#$, silly and no brainer working). Women themselves condemn women bosses. First lessons for women, come off complaining and first be part of the team. We also got to blame men for all this. Many men look at women as a woman and try and engage in sweet talks and enjoy a good feel to be around them. Some men also harass women, which is stupidity. Com'mon guys, grow up, they r there to beat u at yr job and get a promotion ahead of you. They gain by crying, complaining, gossiping and sobbing their problems, what have you men got? Men are too straight and simple. We have no shoulders to cry on and we have to defend ourselves. So growth in India or elsewhere is the same for men of women. It is up to us to be professionals and work towards our own welfare first. Forget women and work your way. Women will get what they want, they have their own ways.
Posted by: Souperman - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
17:Souperman or "Soup"err.. man? Be a man and talk like one. Instead of beating about the bush that women get ahead of men in terms of promotions by crying or complaining, look at the abilities of women, just like you look at the way men have abilities. At the end of the day, a manager looks at his team and the resources in the team - be it man or woman.

The problem here is of gender again. This time it is both men and women. Both are good at blaming or pointing fingers when it comes to problems, but cannot stand up and assertively take decisions to solve the problem nor communicate it to the bosses.

Set aside your pre-conceived notions about women and the problems men have to face, stay put on your goals, focus and acheive your work deliverables. Unless it is a dire circumstance, no promotion will be denied to those who have the ability and hardwork to put into their work.
 AMB replied to: Souperman 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
18:I have not seen such MCP stuff for a long time... real Chauvinistic man... you should get an award.. by the way if you want to be an equal partner, let me give you some input, by law there is also an option for paternity leave... but you care to ignore it because that would mean additional responsibility man... don't be biased.. they are also your sisters and mothers... our own..
 Pradeep replied to: Souperman 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
19: I have seen both Kinds of woman in my 8+ Years Career.
1. Woman bringing Personal Life to office
like Few woman who keep conversing with friends and familiy all the time, bringing their kids to office asking them to wait in reception, taking them to movies, parks in office hrs. But indeed she didnt got any career growth, these kind of people are very annoying and disturbance to others. Family up Career down.
2. Woman bringing Professional Life to family
I had a privilage of working with one lady who used to carry work to home, because of which she had problems in the family front her son grow up without any proper love affection, but she got promoted and career up family down.
3. Balanced
These are the type of woman who are balanced and always know what to do in office and also at home so that nothing conflicts with each other. These are kind of woman who prosper in their Career.

Same principle applies to men too
Posted by: Vihari Sharma - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
20:What I think there should be proper time management both from employer side and employee side come on time leave at time this should be theory. There are people who will involve in unnecessary gossip most of the time at office hour but work till late in office this is true for both men and women so its not male or female its the kind of humane behaviour. Balanced life style is only answer for these stupid questions.
 Shivani replied to: Vihari Sharma 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
21: But Vihari, does the child also not belong to the father? then why can't you or the father of the child take care of it? So when that happens and they bring the children to work place it is fine is it? Why does it annoy you to see children at work place? Is it a Male attitude... the new management theories say that children should be given a place in the office so that both the mother and father can look after their children with care, love and affection. Think of it this way - what if both your parents were working because they had to make ends meet - would you have preferred to be in somebody else's care or your parents care - be honest in answering... ultimately we are all here to live a life not to work and not relate with others...
 Pradeep replied to:  Shivani 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
22: misconceptions not only cripple women but also men's career.far instance, SASTRA is currently having a Dean who is short tempered ,cynic and a jerk,who with his personal vengence and negative attitude has made the life of several faculty members in the no.1 school in India to
Posted by: super stars - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
23: misconceptions not only affects women career but men's carer also.in a tannjore university with no.1 biotech school in India has got a new Dean who with his misconception has nade several great faculties to resign.he is a cynic and finds faults on all
Posted by: viradkohli - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
24: Exactly , i knows one, metro, Boss, virtually a left alone, harassing all, service persons, driver, female team mates (better not to mention), all professionals, 30 - 37 yrs , cries almost 3-4 days a week, lost their confidence,
It may be a trick, by the boss to pay less, and not let them to leave her.
Posted by: Danny - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
25: i quite agree with this - leave for person commitments(like that for marriage,pregnancy etc) are interpreted by the supervisor(who is incidentally a male employee in most cases) basis his own perception without consulting the female employee concerned. As such,upwards career movement plans gets affected adversely.
Posted by: Ruby Ray - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
26:I believe that women have good potential to move ahead, but when compared, it appears that their are a lot of negative trait.
I don't think men take care of kids at home as much as women do, about meal (kitchen), we men prefer junk food than cooking, the more open & bold we men are, we tend to break relations.

I feel many women lag the guts to do the right approach, they are not direct & upto point while conversing, not open minded, always tries to keep a safe side for own selves, easily give up & the worst are their LAST & STRONGEST WEAPON their TEARS.
So concluding, we can not put ourselves (men) in their (women)shoes, the best thing is not only giving equal right but also shouldering each others responsibilities.
 Poorvesh Mistry replied to: Ruby Ray 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
27:i personaly fl wmen employees r mre sincre as cmprd to thr countrparts. A strng carer orntd wman is alwys a superwman if she is mard
 Vicas Rajvanshi replied to: Ruby Ray 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
28: Ruby Ray

A superwoman is Xena with everything super and superb. Mard too.
 Bangara replied to:  Vicas Rajvanshi 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
29: your "e" alphbet is not working.. please get it rectified.
 e hater replied to:  Vicas Rajvanshi 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
30: I agree. Females employees are most of the times much more sincere than male employees. They have a sense of loyalty towards the organization and this itself comes form the fact that she is a woman.
 Minisha replied to:  Vicas Rajvanshi 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
31: Hi, can loyalty linked to gender?
 wills  replied to: Minisha 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
32: no
 christiefox replied to: wills 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
33: Write whole words!
 Sushant Danekar replied to:  Vicas Rajvanshi 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
34: It may not be 100% true with male bosses, but i can say there is lot of problems with female bosses to female teamates. because female boss may not have comfortable personal life,she will show all her worries and depressions on innocent people in team, then she try to harass the female teammates as much as possible due to egoness.it happened really. in india particularly in south india, male bosses are having very good behaviour with female teammates, waiting for quick replies.
Posted by: good frnd to all - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
35:It is sad that gender bias still exist and surprisingly even in corporate sector Once I even overheard a manager telling that he prefers to have only male members in his team.Though their behaviour is good with the female employees(outwardly) but when it comes to promotion they always give first preference to male.
 anonymous replied to: good frnd to all 
 post - 18 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
36: Women communicate well in the business environment and understand that fruitful conversations promote sound business relationships and teamwork, thus contributing to an improvement in the bottom line.

Women are usually well organized and manage a dual career, as homemakers and professional employees.

Women often regard their fellow employees as family and take time to ascertain their personal needs. Hence, they can sometimes be taken undue advantage of. Women tend to be detail-oriented at times, thereby causing others to get impatient for results.

Competition is strange for most women because they were not groomed for winning.

Women who achieve powerful positions in the corporate world may be subjected to personal and professional attacks because of their gender. Independent women are strong, fearless, and in control of their homes, families, emotions, and their working environment. They tackle problems with a heads-on approach, being steadfast in their pursuit of success and happiness.

Men and women should operate as a team, both within a corporate environment and outside one, with synergy in mind. Members of either gender should not feel threatened by the presence or performance of the opposite sex. It is important for men and women to realize their differences, and to “dance their way through corporate life,” while always keeping an eye on the bottom line. What we need is a positive approach to life and business in an attempt to increase personal, corporate, national, and international welfare.

It is my policy to distribute free abridged versions of my books on leadership, ethics, teamwork, motivation, women in the workforce, and sexual harassment to anyone who sends a request to crespin79 at primus.ca.

Maxwell Pinto, Business Author
 Maxwell Pinto replied to:  anonymous 
 post - 19 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
37: In my case it is strange
my wife is working in a ok IT co though it belongs to a big group\ the Boss overwhelmes my spouse with real Promotions and fat salaries which is unheard of this time of recession increases it by 70% every year. She has no time for family and has abandoned the family
the boss is always right they say but strangely her Boss isnt alright he has broken my family of nearly 10 people its high time a few cranky stupid boss'es understand. Is all done in his vested interest not evn of the companies - anonymous husband who is undergoing the pain n the entire family suffering.
 anonymous  replied to: Maxwell Pinto 
 post - 22 Nov, 2009
reply Reply   Report this comment  Report abuse
Disclaimer
Messages posted on this Web site under the `Comments' area are solely the opinions of those who have posted them and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd or its site www.siliconindia.com. Gossip, mud slinging and malicious attacks on individuals and organizations are strictly prohibited. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd can not be held responsible for errors or omissions in content, nor for the authenticity of the user/company name or email addresses associated with posted messages. Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd reserves the right to edit or remove messages containing inappropriate language or any other material that could be construed as libelous, potentially libelous, or otherwise offensive or inappropriate.Infoconnect Web Technologies India Pvt Ltd do not endorse the products and services or any other offerings mentioned in these messages.






News:           Technology   |   Enterprise IT   |   Tech Products   |   Startups   |   Finance   |   Business   |   Career   |   Magazine  |   Dailydose   |   News archive   |  
RSS
Network:       Network   |   Profile   |   Messages   |   Scrapbook   |   Find   |   Blogs   |   Communities   |   Events   |   Q&A   |   CXO Insights  
Career:        Jobs   |   Companies   |   Test your skills   |   Mentorship   |   Videos   |   Career blogs   |   Training institutions  |   Freshers
Job training courses:   Web developer   |  Java developer   |   CCNA training
Education:   MBA   |  MCA   |   Engineering   |   US   |   Internship
Life:                  Humor   |    Bookstore   |   Relocate  |  Marketplace
Cities:             Startup   |  Real estate   |   Finance  
Company:   About us   |   Contact   |   Help   |   Community rules   |   Advertise with us
Member directory:   A  B  C  D  E  F  G  H  I  J  K  L  M  N  O  P  Q  R  S  T  U  V  W  X  Y  Z   

and help us continue to improve SiliconIndia
© 2008 SiliconIndia all rights reserved